Bob Pitman started the Pitman Insurance Agency in the spring of 1974. After fifteen years of continued growth, George Morin purchased the Pitman Insurance Agency and renamed the company to Mainstreet Insurance Corporation. At one time, Mainstreet Insurance Corporation had offices in Show Low, Holbrook, Heber, Pinetop and Mesa, Arizona.
In 2016, Ken Stickler and Brent Webb purchased Main Street Insurance Corporation and now operate under the Stickler Webb Insurance brand. With offices in Navajo, Graham, Maricopa and Cochise County, Stickler Webb Insurance continues to carry on the tradition of serving the community beyond being an insurance agent.